As I
remarked in
a recent blog, the insistence by Brexiters that Britain should visibly
increase planning for ‘no deal’ in order to ‘show the EU we mean business’ has had
the curious effect that they are now complicit in articulating what they
simultaneously dismiss as ‘Project Fear’.
It is indeed
extraordinary that we now have a British government talking quite seriously
about contingency plans
to stockpile food and medicines in anticipation of something that could be
a real possibility in just nine months’ time.
So much
about Brexit is outrageous that it has almost lost its power to shock, but we
shouldn’t become inured. We’re actually talking about emergency preparations
that may be needed not because of an unavoidable crisis being forced upon us but
because of a policy the government thinks it is reasonable to pursue, if only
as a fall back. Needless to say, nothing remotely like this is what was promised
by the leave campaign just a couple of years’ ago, as Lewis
Goodall of Sky News pointed out today.
This opens
up the possibility for public opinion to shift decisively against Brexit.
However, those hoping for such a shift need to understand that it cannot by any
means be taken for granted.
The reasons for
that are various. One, which is difficult for those who are deeply enmeshed in
the issue to understand, is that many people just
aren’t very interested in Brexit or heavily invested in it either way. Even
those who may have been briefly engaged by the referendum are now in many cases
bored. And that has inevitably become more so as the debates have become
ever-more arcane and technical. Few can get worked up about the pros and cons
of a Facilitated Customs Arrangement, for example.
As for the
more general debate, it has just become repetitious and robotic. Few hearing
that, say, we must ‘take back control of our borders, our money, and our laws’
will respond ‘gosh, that’s something new to think about’: they will respond
positively or negatively as they have always done or, more likely, just tune it
out.
However, the
talk of emergency preparations adds a new, more dramatic and readily
understandable dimension to things. Even so, many voters may just assume that
in the end, they will sort things out; ‘they’, of course, being the much
despised ‘political class’.
Committed
Brexiters, though, have a rather different reaction as is evident on social
media or in the comment sections of the pro-Brexit newspapers. For them –
despite the point about this having been initiated by the Brexiters themselves
– the project fear cliché is the first port of call. Beyond that, all the
familiar litany of excuses as to why Brexiters bear no responsibility for
Brexit kicks in. None of this would be happening if Brexit had been ‘properly
done’, or hadn’t been ‘betrayed by remainers’. Or it is attributed to EU
‘punishment’ rather than being a consequence of Brexit. As an aside, it is a
peculiar feature of Brexiter reasoning that we should leave the EU because it
is a nasty,
tyrannical mafia-like organization and, yet, we should expect it to be benevolent
to a departing member. There’s a version of the same thing in Dominic
Raab’s comment that the EU is irresponsible to be publishing its no deal
plans, whereas it is eminently responsible for the UK to do so.
All these
are variants of the strange, circular Brexiter logic which I
have discussed in detail elsewhere. In that logic, every new event is
re-interpreted as proof that Brexit is right. Thus whereas before they argued
that Brexit was easy, when it is shown to be difficult it ‘just goes to prove’
that Britain is far too enmeshed with the EU and so we have to leave. That goes
right down to the level of food and medicine shortages in that the more extreme
the consequences the more they ‘prove’ the need to leave. Plus, as I
wrote in a previous post but will repeat it (as I like the formulation) some
– a minority, perhaps – will actually be excited by the chaos of a no deal,
whether because of adolescent anarcho-liberal dreams of purification through
crisis or Dad’s Army nostalgia for Lord Woolton Pie and
digging for victory.
For those
wedded to this ‘logic’, no event, no argument, no fact will make them change
their mind. But it’s important not make the same error that Brexiters make when
they claim that all 17.4 million who voted leave were of the same mind and had the
same intentions. That claim is manifestly nonsense and is made entirely
dishonestly in order to urge a particular – invariably hard line –
interpretation of the result.
By the same
token, by no means all of the 17.4 million are trapped in the perverse logic
that I’ve just outlined. Let’s say – this is only a guess – it is true for half
of them. If so, it is the other half – those who have turned off and/or are
open to changing their minds - who are now crucial. If, say, half of those came
to the view that Brexit was a mistake then that would represent a decisive
shift in public opinion.
Yet at the
same time it shouldn’t be assumed that all those who voted remain are, or ever
were, rock solid remainers. Some of those will also have turned off, and others
will have changed their minds. Some will, themselves, have been swayed by the
‘EU is punishing us’ narrative or be drawn to that view by the no deal
contingency planning. Indeed it’s clear that Brexiters are now pitching exactly
that narrative to people ‘regardless of how they voted’, as in a
typically mendacious piece by Daniel Hannan in The Sun today.
As things
stand, opinion
polls still show not far short of half the electorate would vote for Brexit
again if there were a second referendum. True that means that remain would win,
but we know that almost until the 2016 vote that looked to be the case: were
there to be another vote after another no doubt equally duplicitous campaign
the result might be the same. Crucially, without a sustained and significant
change in the opinion polls there is little reason for politicians to sense a
pressure from public opinion to change course.
In that
context, the next few months represent a small window of possibility for the
implications of no deal to sway opinion, especially if they continue to spelt
out as starkly as has begun to be the case in the last few days. But it really
is a very small window. There is barely enough time to see a sustained shift and even if it happened
all the complexities of how that could lead to a different policy, or another
referendum, remain as intractable as ever.
It should
also be recognized that spelling out the fearful consequence of no deal has the
potential to lead to a very bad outcome. That’s because, by contrast, any kind
of deal could be greeted with relief. Suppose, for example, it led to something
like the Chequers’ Proposal being the terms of exit (unlikely, of course, that
the EU would agree it)? Or some other wretched fudge gets cobbled together. This
might then be seen by MPs and the public as a kind of triumph even though it
would, in fact, be hugely damaging. Moreover, it would please neither leavers
nor remainers and do nothing to bring an end to the bitterness or even provide
a stable basis for the future. Yet such a dismal scenario could be arrived at
just for fear of something even worse.
It would be
a silly season story, but Brexit is now a year round silly story so when Dominic
Raab pronounced that the UK might withhold paying its outstanding debts to
the EU if there was no trade deal agreement it has to be taken seriously. Raab,
bear in mind, is a hardcore Brexiter who has just been made Brexit Secretary
and this was one of his first public statements in the role.
Raab’s
threat and the phase 1 agreement
The folly of
it can hardly be overstated. This is a payment that Britain has already
undertaken, in
the phase 1 agreement, to make. Many commentators are pointing out that the
Article 50 talks are sequenced, with phase 2 being about trade and the phase 1
agreement is not contingent on the second phase. But there is more to it than
this. The Article 50 process will not and cannot yield a trade deal. It can
yield a broad agreement about a future trade deal but that deal itself will
take much longer and would be completed (if at all) under a different process.
Thus Raab’s
threat is, in a sense, meaningless. But that does not mean it will have no
effect. Its effect is to further undermine trust, just when it is most needed.
Just as his predecessor David Davis’s airy dismissal of the phase 1 agreement
on the Irish border backstop made it vital to the EU to nail that down in a
legal text in the Withdrawal Agreement, so will Raab’s statement strengthen the
case to make the agreement on the payment watertight.
After all,
this payment will not be made in one lump sum but over many years into the
future. It is absurd to think that the EU would leave any wriggle room on it,
especially with all the noises off from the Ultras that, once over the March
2019 line, anything agreed is up for grabs again. Raab’s threat is all of a
piece with this, and takes us back to the very early days after the Referendum
when Brexiters were denying that any payment at all needed to be made, and that
the EU could ‘go whistle’ for the money owed. It is a posture which damages not
just negotiations with the EU but to Britain’s more general credibility as a
reliable negotiating partner. And trust matters
in international negotiations.
It’s worth
recalling how the phase 1 agreement came about. At the time, the government
were desperate for it to happen both in order to show progress and to indicate
to businesses and individuals that there could be a transition period. It was
for this reason that it agreed not just the financial settlement, but
provisions for citizens’ rights and for the Northern Ireland backstop.
Subsequently, ministers crowed that they had defied the nay-sayers who doubted
a phase 1 deal was possible. Now, they have all but disowned what they agreed
to.
Brexiter
anger and aggression
This latest
episode is illustrative of the entire way that Brexiters and the government
have approached the process. Apart from some generous and emollient comments
from Theresa May, especially in the Florence
speech, the tone has been unrelentingly sour, grudging and, often, aggressive
and hectoring; the ubiquitous references to the Brexit ‘war cabinet’ being one
example. As I’ve
remarked before, Brexiters often act as if the EU were forcing Britain to
leave.
The irony is
that Brexiters urge remainers to embrace the positive, even glorious,
opportunities that they claim Brexit brings. Imagine if they had approached the
exit process in that way. Then, it would have been open and generous-minded. We
are entering a great and prosperous future: a few billion over many years to
settle our liabilities is nothing by comparison. An immediate, unilateral
guarantee to EU citizens would be no problem. A long-tapered role for the ECJ
in relation to those citizens would be a minor matter. What can such
trivialities matter now that we rejoice in being free! At the same time, a
realistic proposal for the future could have been proposed, which either did
not begin from rigid red lines or which accepted the implications of those red
lines for what could be achieved.
But of
course nothing remotely like that has happened. That is partly because the
Brexit Ultras are so suffused with hatred of the EU that it has permeated the
entire approach to leaving. Talks had barely started before some Ultras were
calling for Britain to walk out of them. It’s also because of their anger at
finding that – as they were warned – there was never going to be an agreement
to allow Britain to effectively stay in the single market but without budget
payments, ECJ and freedom of movement. Indeed it is that which has meant that
although phase 1 was concluded last December, nothing has really happened since
because the government still can’t seem to understand it.
So, now, the
Brexiters are ramping up the anger levels and talking in ever wilder terms
about leaving without any deal at all. This takes us from the realm of
silliness to that of real danger. Apart from the many economic
calamities, we now have a senior business
leader talking of the possibility of civil disorder (£), and level-headed
legal experts discussing as a genuine prospect the use of government
emergency powers. This is a million miles from what leave campaigners told
voters that Brexit would be like which makes a mockery of their perpetual,
robotic grinding out of the absurd line that whatever happens now is the sacred
and unchallengeable ‘will of the people’.
A void where
government should be
A
responsible government would not have allowed things to get to this point. But
it is no exaggeration to say that, as regards Brexit policy, Britain doesn’t
actually have a functioning government. It seems to be the omnipresent
Rees-Mogg more than the cabinet which is determining that policy, to the extent
that it is not even clear any more whether the Chequers’ proposal – hopeless
as it is – is actually the government’s current negotiating position or
not. Likewise with Raab’s threat: is this now government policy? Or is he
speaking for himself? No one knows.
Similarly, a
responsible government would have tried to lead and shape public discourse
about the EU which has long been degraded, in the last couple of years been
toxic, and is now in danger of becoming completely unhinged. Having refused to
disown the tabloid assault on ‘enemies of the people’ and ‘saboteurs’, the
government itself now stands accused of ‘treachery’.
Meanwhile,
the ever-growing EU punishment narrative is given succour not just by the
out-and-out headbangers but
by the new Foreign Secretary. His message that the British public would
blame the EU for a no deal Brexit was only a diplomatic version of what in the
social media swamp re-appears as undiluted hatred. A better and more leaderly
message would have been to the British people, explaining why the punishment
narrative is misplaced. But all roads lead back to the Tory Party’s civil war,
and for Hunt (a remainer turned Breliever, who may well harbour leadership
ambitions) to have done so would be to be open to attack for the heresy of what are now being putridly called 'remainer tendencies'.
The highly respected
Brexit commentator, David
Allen Green, wrote today about the need for those expressing alarm about
the possibility of no deal to be calm (though not complacent) and gave several sound
reasons for this. That is no doubt good advice, and could be extended across
the spectrum to those ramping up
the pressure for there to be no deal as well as those fearing it. But,
again, it is really only the government which can fill the void here, by
providing the calm leadership to do so, and that is not possible when there is
a void at the heart of where government should be.
The summer
may provide a breathing space for everyone, but once the silly season is over
the government need to get serious. This farce could very soon turn into a
tragedy. Just today, a reputable British newspaper, The Times, carried an opinion
piece lauding the virtues of autocratic leadership over democracy. A straw
in the wind, perhaps, of the kind of politics that the combination of Brexit chaos
and Brexit
McCarthyism could take us to.
We’ve seen
that movie, and it doesn’t end at all well.